This week on American Horror Story Freak Show the plot felt a bit muddled, but perhaps that was because lots of things happened in preparation for the end of the season story arc. The Tattler sisters returned to the freak show, Dell committed attempted murder and then committed murder, and Penny’s father Lost His Shit. (Warning: Spoilers below!)
The Tattler Sisters, Jimmy, and Elsa
At the beginning of the episode, Jimmy is at the Mott household, trying to get Dot and Bette to go home to the freak show with him. Dot knows that Dandy isn’t what he seems, is probably incredibly dangerous, but Bette, who is absolutely in love, doesn’t want to go back to the show. She does, though.
And somehow, in the middle of all of this, Jimmy decides to practice singing “Come as You Are.” The musical number seemed an odd fit here, not the right song or something. But anyhow, Jimmy is really mad at Elsa, so he’s practicing to her. He’s practicing grunge to her. Of course she hates it, and Jimmy is ready to reveal to the freaks that orchestrated the disappearance of Dot and Bette. But Dot and Bette lie, saying that Elsa helped them experience a life of luxury. In exchange, they’re plotting all sorts of prices–a new act, caviar in bed, half the box office proceeds, etc.
Elsa seems willing to grant some of their wishes. In one of the show’s more bizarre-but-fun scenes, Bette colors her hair blonde, wears an abundance of makeup, and laughs that she and Dot will be “the perfect before and after.” Dot’s the before, of course. While she’s prattling, Elsa and Dot are having a conversation through passed notes–one that we hear through the mouths of Floating Head Dot and Floating Head Elsa. In black and white. It’s weird, but it works. Dot, of course, wants Elsa to find the doctor who performed the surgery on the twins, and she wants to be ride of Bette.
Dell and Jimmy
And across town, Dell is perplexed, by a whole other issue. He can’t understand why he hasn’t seen his lover around lately, and he returns to the bar to search for him. Stanley notes his appearance at such a place, though, and begins to use Dell’s sexuality as blackmail. The price of silence is for Dell to help Stanley turn the freak show into an exhibit for the museum.
Somehow, Dell decides that the proper first victim for him is Amazon Eve. Even for a strong man, this seems like a stupid move. Eve is tall, strong, and heavy—difficult to kill and to transport. But he makes the stupid decision, trying to chloroform her in her sleep. Consequently, Dell gets his ass kicked. “Who’s the strongman now” Eve asks.
Dell goes to another bar to drink away his defeat. Jimmy interrupts him, has a drink. Dell seems about to kill Jimmy, but changes his mind, acknowledges him as a son. Somehow the two are friends, and this seems like a Bad Thing.
Paul and Penny
Penny thought it would be a good idea to go home. I suppose she needed clothes or something? But her father, of course, is waiting for her. And he has a surprise. Honestly, it’s one of the most bizarre surprises that AHS has thrown at its fans so far, and it’s Morris the Tattoo Artist. Morris gets to work tattooing Penny’s face and forking her tongue. Yep—Daddy hired a tattoo artist and body modifier to screw up his little girl’s face so that she would no longer be recognizable as his daughter. Damn.
When Penny returns to the freak show, Paul is furious. It’s clear that he also feels responsible for what has happened. I can only hope that whatever more drama unfolds there, it will include Something Else About Morris.
This week saw the death of Ma Petite at the hands of Dell. The body count has been relatively small on AHSFS so far, and watching Dell crush Ma Petite against him was a heart-in-throat moment. There was little doubt, after seeing Dell attack Amazon Eve, that what we were seeing was happening, was not a Pink Cupcakes moment of imagination. It’s also a good indication of Dell’s character that when he couldn’t take on the largest, strongest person in the camp, he chose the smallest.
And then, seeing Ma Petite’s small body suspended, preserved as an exhibit at the museum was shocking–she makes the third (fourth?) character that we’ve seen in the exhibit so far, though the first that we’ve seen die. My hunch is that we’ve seen the first of what will be many deaths resulting in a full exhibit by the show’s end.
It looks as though, when the show (and I) return week-after-next, we’ll see more of the situation between Penny and Paul unfold as well as some repercussions of actions taken by some of the characters.
Episode Grade: C+. This was one of the few episodes I haven’t watched closely because, while there was a lot going on, a few scenes dragged, and the plot seemed to fold into itself at times. An average episode, but we’ve seen way better this season.